Peace Action: Talking Points that Oppose Trump’s Statement today on Iraq

Gabe Murphy

Communications Associate
Peace Action and the Peace Action Education Fund
Work: (800) 949-9020 ext 133
Cell: (510) 501-3345
Twitter: @GabeRMurphy

Iran Deal Messaging Beyond the Basics:

SUMMARY:

1. The Iran nuclear agreement is working and making us safer. Thanks to the agreement, all of Iran’s potential pathways to obtaining nuclear weapons remain blocked.

2. Political motivations, not national security interests, are driving President Trump’s policies on Iran.

3. Walking away from the agreement would increase the risk of confrontation with Iran.

4. Walking away from the agreement would damage America’s credibility on the world stage, and undermine prospects for negotiating with North Korea or other countries.

DETAILS:

1. The Iran nuclear agreement is working and making us safer. Thanks to the agreement, all of Iran’s potential pathways to obtaining nuclear weapons remain blocked.

A. Under the agreement, Iran forfeited 98 percent of its enriched uranium, decommissioned two-thirds of its centrifuges, poured cement into the core of its Arak reactor and took other actions that moved its breakout time — the amount of time it would take to produce enough uranium for one crude nuclear weapon — from 2-3 months to at least a year.

B. The Iran agreement includes one of the most robust inspection and verification regimes in history, utilizing technology to verify Iran’s compliance and granting the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) unprecedented access to Iran’s nuclear facilities.

C. The IAEA [1], the European Union [2], over 80 nuclear policy experts [3], Chairman of the Joint Chiefs Gen. Joseph Dunford [4] and Secretary of Defense Jim Mattis [5] have all said Iran is adhering to the terms of the agreement.

2. Political motivations, not national security interests, are driving President Trump’s policies on Iran.

A. During the election, Trump scored easy political points with his base by railing against one of President Obama’s key foreign policy achievements.

B. President Trump has expressed a desire to decertify Iran’s compliance with the agreement regardless of whether there is material evidence to support such a claim.

C. President Trump’s own Secretary of Defense has said he believes the Iran agreement is in America’s national security interest, yet the president still appears intent on scrapping the deal.

3. Walking away from the agreement would increase the risk of confrontation with Iran.

A. Walking away from the agreement would remove all the restrictions on Iran’s nuclear program, and end the international community’s access to Iran’s nuclear facilities.

B. If the agreement collapses, Iran will likely resume enriching higher levels of uranium, which would put war with Iran back on the table as one way, albeit an incredibly dangerous and ill-advised way, to prevent Iran from obtaining nuclear weapons.

C. War with Iran would be catastrophic, costing countless lives and taxpayer dollars and destabilizing yet another country in the region, or worse, causing a regional war.

4. Walking away from the agreement would damage America’s credibility on the world stage and undermine prospects for negotiating with North Korea or other countries.

A. If the administration de-certifies Iran without cause or takes other steps to undermine the agreement, that will send a signal across the world that the U.S. cannot be trusted to live up to its international commitments.

B. If Congress reenacts sanctions on Iran without evidence of a material violation, that could spell doom for efforts to negotiate with North Korea, which is the only viable option for deescalating tensions and curbing North Korea’s nuclear program.

Suggested Hashtags:

#IranDeal

#NoWarWithIran

#SaveTheIranDeal

#DiplomacyWorks

REFERENCES:

[1] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-08-31/iran-sticking-to-nuclear-agreement-with-powers-iaea-reports

[2] https://www.armscontrol.org/blog/2017-09-21/p51-iran-nuclear-deal-alert-september-2017

[3] https://www.armscontrol.org/pressroom/2017-09/more-80-nuclear-nonproliferation-experts-reaffirm-support-iran-nuclear-deal

[4] http://thehill.com/policy/defense/352463-top-general-says-iran-complying-with-nuclear-deal

[5] http://www.politico.com/story/2017/10/03/jim-mattis-iran-deal-243411

____________________________________________________________
This list is for Peace Action affiliate, associate group and chapter leaders, staff, volunteers and board members.You received this message as a subscriber on the list:
paaffiliates@xmail.peace-action.org

To be removed from the list, send any message to:
paaffiliates-unsubscribe@xmail.peace-action.org

To be added to the list, send any message to:
paaffiliates-subscribe@xmail.peace-action.org

To change your email preferences, your email address and access shared files see:
http://xmail.peace-action.org/lists/info/paaffiliates

Advertisements

Howard County Peace Action

Howard County Peace Action is a new chapter affiliated with Peace Action, the largest grass-roots peace organization in the country. Based in Columbia, Maryland, it is part of Maryland Peace Action along with sister chapters, Peace Action Montgomery (http://www.peaceactionmc.org) and Anne Arundel Peace Action (http://www.mdpeaceaction.org.)

albert_einstein

Albert Einstein (1879-1955)

We take as our touchstone this expression of Einstein’s:

“May the conscience and the commonsense of the peoples be awakened, so that we may reach a new stage in the life of nations, where people will look back on war as an incomprehensible aberration of their forefathers.”

These words, spoken by a truly brilliant, great and compassionate man, whose wisdom  extended to human affairs, suggest that in the future humankind would view war not as inevitable but, indeed, as a horrible anomaly.  Our nation and the peoples of the world must take a very different path, and we wish to contribute, as best we can, to this noble cause.

Our recent activities 

Howard County Peace Action grew out of the Howard County Coalition for Peace and Justice, (HCCPJ) a local and active group formed to protest the first Gulf War.

We changed our name and broadened our affiliation in June of 2012. We voted to join national Peace Action to help do our part to:

  • Eliminate the threat of nuclear war
  • Foster the use of diplomacy over military force
  • Convert a defense-based economy to one that meets domestic needs (and helps pay for reversing climate change)
  • Share the resources, dynamism and stimulation of a national office (established over 50 years ago!) as well as our sister chapters.

In the last few years, we have:

  • Opposed efforts by legislators to undermine ongoing multilateral negotiations with Iran over its nuclear program;
  • Supported the control of Iran’s nuclear program through negotiation
  • Lobbied our federal representatives and held a vigil to prevent a U.S. attack on Syria and re-engagement in Iraq;
  • Protested the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, P.M. Netanyahu’s speech before Congress, and called for a two-State solution;
  • Lobbied representatives in Annapolis and Washington on behalf of Fund Our Communities: Not the Pentagon for economic conversion to prevent domestic cuts and increase defense cuts;
  • Lobbied representatives in Howard County and Annapolis to reform or eliminate solitary confinement in State prisons;
  • Worked to Get the Money Out (of politics) – Maryland Chapter;
  • Supported imprisoned whistleblower Chelsea Manning;
  • Invited these speakers: Phyllis Bennis, a well-known Middle East expert; Mel Goodman, author of National Insecurity; and Kevin Martin, the Peace Action Executive Director.

Campaigns & Action! 

peace_with_iran21

 

Campaign: Diplomacy with Iran  This was a hard-fought struggle and our most successful and significant recent campaign.  Peace Action, as part of a broad coalition of peace groups, supported negotiation with Iran over war (with six nations) on a comprehensive nuclear deal.  The Iranians have made good on their side of the agreement: sending over 8.5 tons of enriched uranium to Russia so Iran can’t use that in bomb-making, disabled more than 12,000 centrifuges and poured concrete into the core of a reactor at Arak designed to produce plutonium.  As President Obama said, we have”cut off every single single path Iran could have used to build a bomb” and noted that engagement with Iran has created a “window to try to resolve important issues.”  The New York Times wrote in an editorial on January 17, 2016,  “The world is now safer for this.”

We told our Democratic representatives not to help Republicans torpedo the Iran deal! Our position was: Let diplomacy take its course!  Click on:  http://petitions.moveon.org/sign/democrats-dont-side-with?source=c.em&r_by=1135580

Campaign: Fund our Communities: Not the Pentagon.  This campaign intends to redirect obscene Pentagon overspending toward socially useful purposes and pressing national needs, especially to minimize climate change, as the photo, above, portrays. You may ask, where will we get the money for combatting such ills as climate change, inequality and racism, rotting infrastructure and poor education? It is an aim of Peace Action and Fund our Communities to at least get the enormous down payment for such items by redirecting the priorities of the military budget.

The campaign — to bring about a national process of economic conversion — is waged by many Peace Action affiliates, including HCPA, and especially by Peace Action Montgomery http://www.peaceactionmc.org. In Maryland alone, we had a 62-organization coalition pushing for it, including the AFL-CIO and the NAACP. The feasibility of economic conversation has decades of research behind it. See Institute for Policy Studies: http://www.ips-dc.org/authors/miriam-pemberton/

On a national level, we work with the National Priorities Project, a Nobel Prize nominee, that provides an analytical overview of the Federal budget and educational leadership on national priorities. We are talking about military bloat–unneeded equipment, war planes and ships, and over 1000 military bases abroad! The US. “Defense” Department budget accounts for 54% of all federal discretionary spending. That’s larger than the next seven largest military budgets around the world combined! This defies commonsense and as Einstein said, “…may the commonsense of the peoples be awakened…”

Help shrink the Pentagon!   Click here: https://www.nationalpriorities.org.

  • Campaign for a Nuclear Weapons Free World  In 2007, 46 organizations joined forces to create the Campaign for a Nuclear Weapons Free World to promote practical steps today to free the world from nuclear weapons tomorrow.  There are now more than 150 organizations that have joined this coalition. The coalition calls on Congress and President Obama to make a world free of nuclear weapons an urgent priority, and to demonstrate U.S. leadership by taking steps to realize this goal.Here is a promising and hopeful campaign. They need our help!Learn more: http://nuclearweaponsfree.org/aboutus/

Important links and resources:

Join Us!    —

http://www.peace-action.org/action